Monday, January 15, 2024

1/22…Labaree’s “From Citizen to Consumers”

In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a question about something you didn’t understand or that you’d like to know more about.  

27 comments:

  1. After reading this article, one takeaway I have is the purposes of schooling shifting from citizens to consumers. A political rationale is the concept of shoring up the new republic vs a market rationale which promotes social efficiency and social mobility. One question I have is, if we continue to change the "goals" of public education, does this mean educators will be required to complete more tests to verify their understanding and qualifications?

    ReplyDelete
  2. One statement I have is that education has come a long way and that includes bad and good. One question I have is, Will the goals of education keep changing throughout time.

    ReplyDelete
  3. One thing I took away from the text was that Labaree mentioned that in the school system we have showed more interest in getting a diploma than a education.This stuck with me because I feel like the system really just focuses on a person's credentials and diploma's more than what they actually know. What can we do to fix this?

    ReplyDelete
  4. A takeaway I got from reading this article is that diverse perspectives exist regarding the reasons for pursuing education. One question that I have is wil the goals of education continue to accelerate or stay where they are?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I realized by reading this article that there are differing opinions among people concerning the value of education. Although I've been in school for a long time and have experience teaching, the complexity of the educational system is something that is always changing motivationally. A question I have is if the goals of education are always changing, how long is it before an education in general or a higher-level education is determined insignificant and not worth it to society?

    ReplyDelete
  6. In this article, I found the author’s breakdown of the three major social goals of the education system to be very interesting. I never really thought of school as school as a way to mobilize people into being tax payers. I feel like the main focus of how school is portrayed is a way to focus on individual goals. This thought brings me into my question relating to the true nature of the education system. Could there be other more sinister goals of the education system possibly dealing with control?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Vicky: One big take away from reading this article is that the education system has a lot of reasons for existing that isn't just to benefit those being educated. I learned that it is really tied into different politics. However, one question I still have after reading this is why is it important for politics to be included in educational systems? can we not have an educational system that values education just for the sake of having an education and expanding our own minds?

    ReplyDelete
  8. The biggest comment that stuck out to me during the reading happened to be at the very end where it states, "from a source of political community to a source of individual opportunity". Whereas I believe politics are an important aspect in education, it seems that it has been starting to take over education. From a personal standpoint, I have seen that the "No child left behind act" can negatively impact a child, my question would be that whereas the concept is positive, I wonder if there is a different route to that end goal.

    ReplyDelete
  9. One take away I had was how the schooling systems contribute to the political state of the US. The way that kids grow up in school, they are conditioned to do what they are learning in school. One question I had was, is private educations causing more harm to the educational system than good?

    ReplyDelete
  10. One thing I took away from the article was the disparity of accessibility to education. Another was how much the type of education you receive and the impact it has on your future. A question I have after reading the article is how could we have an impact on bettering the quality of education when the education system is structured the way it is, how could someone implement these policies on a wide scale?

    ReplyDelete
  11. After reading the article, one takeaway is that the different types of education you have growing up can/will affect your future. Students have also led different lives depending on what they've learned to do in school. My question would be, can education and politics move to be separate in schools?

    ReplyDelete
  12. One thing I can take away is that the education system has classes and depending on your class can vastly affect your educational outcome, however, school allows for the opportunity to expose children to many diverse cultures and allow for personal and social growth. My question would be how people could use education as a means to break diverse incomes in unprivileged schools?

    ReplyDelete
  13. One thing that I took away from this reading is that political/educational reform impacts the future of the political and economic sphere. This in turn impacts the public and private sphere, influencing childhood development in a myriad of ways. A question I have is how do we incorporate the understanding of education as an institution for the future and reflection of society today into policies that make education accessible and applicable to the intersectional experiences individuals face?

    ReplyDelete
  14. Something that I took away from this article is, although we have come a long way in developing our school system there is still major flaws and as Labaree calls it a "failure". One question that I have after reading this article would be, is there actually anything we can do in this day and age that will make all of those difficulties and problems in the school system change or go away completely?

    ReplyDelete
  15. After reading this article, one takeaway was that the competing social goal section made me think more about the education system. I feel that as a black student in America, I feel that we stop fighting for more rights in school because a lot of black kids are not given the same opportunities even though society looks at everybody getting equal opportunities. After all, schools aren't separated anymore. However many counselors won't let black students know about DE and AP courses like they would for white students. A question I have is how as a school and society can we push minority students in the school system and how can we try to improve the curriculum in poorer areas

    ReplyDelete
  16. One takeaway I had from Labaree was how he described the structure of the education system shifted as a result of a focus on the market. I thought it was interesting how the goals and structure of the system changed as a whole in response to a more democratic ideology. One question I have is why has the focus for schooling shifted to consumerism and the market.

    ReplyDelete
  17. One thing I took away from this article was that political beliefs have always been involved in education and that has mostly depended on what the societal beliefs are at the time. One question I have is what are changes that schools could make to be more beneficial to society?

    ReplyDelete
  18. My biggest takeaway from the article is how school was created to be a fix for many problems in society, but as time went on, we strayed from the original goal and now actively feed into the bigger issue. American Public schools have become biased, with only some schools having the materials needed to help their students and limiting students to the viewpoints of only those around them. Question: Has the majority of content currently being taught in schools become irrelevant to our generation?

    ReplyDelete
  19. The biggest takeaway I had from just skimming this article is how those in charge of the education system have varying goals for the American public education system and that these goals have been heavily influenced by the state of national and International politics. my top question is related to this by asking how do we as a system get to a point where the education received in one county is equal to that received in a higher income county and ensuring that any changes made to the education system are for the benefit of learners?

    ReplyDelete
  20. In this article the main takeaway I got was how the main goals of education contradict. I always knew these where their goals to some extent but never fully processed how the education system is broken because of those goals clashing. The mentioning of adding more advanced classes because of more and more students being added to schools to add some sense of separation interested me. If this is the case will higher education continue to lose more and more value and continue to grow or at some point just stay at a certain place?

    ReplyDelete
  21. My main takeaway is that the school system prioritizes conditioning people for the workforce, while neglecting the quality and effectiveness of the education.
    Question: Instead of standardized testing, what can be used to measure students’ learning?

    ReplyDelete
  22. The main takeaway that I got from the reading was how much politics has taken over the educational system. Rather than them trying to make a genuine fix to the issues at hand, they continue to make the issue larger and larger, and they will continue to do so because it helps politicians with their campaigns.
    A question I have is why do we continue to do standardized testing, especially when students have a chronically mediocre academic performance and consistently score below average? We have gotten to a point where there's nothing to even show off.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Labaree's "From Citizen to Consumers" prompts reflection on the changing aims of education. Readers note a shift from emphasizing citizenship to prioritizing individual success and consumerism. This transition raises questions about balancing personal achievement with societal needs. a question that I had was: How can education reconcile these diverging goals effectively?

    ReplyDelete
  24. A takeaway is is the concept of the shift in education from a focus on citizenship to a focus on consumerism. Labaree argues that historically, education in the United States was primarily seen as a means to prepare citizens for participation in democracy. However, over time, there has been a shift towards viewing education as a commodity and students as consumers, with an emphasis on individual achievement and economic success.
    A question is how have educators adapted their approaches to teaching and designing curriculum to meet the demands of a more consumer-driven education?

    ReplyDelete

1/22…Labaree’s “From Citizen to Consumers”

In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...