What do you think the filmmaker is trying to convey about democracy? What was new to you? What did the film contribute to your understanding of what democracy is and/or can be?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1/22…Labaree’s “From Citizen to Consumers”
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
What do you think the filmmaker is trying to convey about democracy? What was new to you? What did the film contribute to your understanding...
-
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
Have you done much thinking about democracy and what our schools might/should have to do with it? If so, what have you been thinking? If not...
I think the filmmaker is trying to convey that democracy can not be easily defined. Instead we all have our own personal definitions of what democracy is or should be. I had no clue about the environment in prison that was described or even in the healthcare industry. I think the film has helped me see that democracy is good in theory but not necessarily in practice.
ReplyDeleteI feel that the filmmaker is trying to convey that democracy is different throughout the world but at the same time similar in so many ways. The information that was new to me is how democracy works in other countries such as Italy & Greece. It helped me understand that democracy is the gap between the poor and rich people. I believe that democracy can be the support between every person on this planet.
ReplyDeleteThe last post was from Taleah
DeleteI think the film makers are trying to explain how there is no direct definition of democracy. It is an idea that is different for each community it is used in. this idea was new to me because growing up in the US we really only are told about democracy from our governmental standpoints and aren't told about how it can differ between countries or how it is used outside of government.
ReplyDeleteEli-I think that the film is trying to show that democracy is always changing. That everyone has their own personal definition and it's different everywhere. The new thing to me was how democracy is in other nations it's not something I've ever really thought about. The film introduced me to the history of democracy which is not something I've ever thought about.
ReplyDeleteI think the filmmaker is trying to say that various places have different forms of democracy. It kinda shows this in my opinion when it flips between the US and the other country that is in the documentary. It's also trying to convey that the US seems to have a very flawed version of democracy considering the people don't even feel like our own democracy is okay. like even super young people in the US. what was new to me was the last guy who went to jail, what he said about the library. I feel like I may be pretty naive for not knowing this but I didn't really know that jails had libraries. but was even more shocking than that was that they're able to just take them away. both of those things were really new to me and super surprising. I think the film is really making me realize that like we really don't live in a full and true democracy. It's like we live in a "democracy", only for show. I also feel like it's contributing to me realizing other places also struggle with their democracy and it can be better.
ReplyDeleteI think the film marker was trying to convey that everyone has their own definition of democracy. Something new I learned is about the prison life and democracy in that range. The film helped me understand the history of democracy and democracy the world.
ReplyDeleteCiara Norfleet
DeleteI think that the film maker is trying to convey that democracy cannot be described by just one person or definition. By interviewing the public and educators, she provides the audience with views from all types of people. I think that it is important to note the film's representation of minorities and genders, as that plays a major role in todays society. Something that was new to me was the repesentation of democracy in other countries, because I have never seen it from that perspective. I would like to think that I have a good understanding of what contributes to democracy in the education system. So by watching the film, I was also able to become more knowledgeable in democracy on its own.
ReplyDeleteI think the filmmaker is trying to show the complexity of democracy and how it means different things to different people and how their backgrounds are a huge part of why they believe what they believe. I didn't know that the original use of democracy was random as in the leaders were chosen at random because every man has 'the capacity to run the business of the city'. This film showed me that democracy can be anything that we want it to be and that it can be improved significantly. Since there is no true meaning of democracy it can be what we choose if we have the correct people leading us.
ReplyDeleteI believe that the filmmaker were trying to showed that the democracy was like a union and everything who decides things because it was needed back then due to lack of manpower and the leaders that governs it showed that they understood what it's like to be every man for themselves. In this film, democracy is not really defined but instead have people govern what it's like to be a union and I think that's what we called a democracy.
ReplyDeleteI think the filmmaker was trying to show that the democracy we have today is not ideal. We are taught that democracy is the best system because everyone has a voice, however in practice that is not the truth. In this country the voices of the cooperation's and people with money outweigh everyone else. Not only that, people who have gone to jail still can't vote even after they have served there sentence. I think democracy can work but we would need to restructure the system we have today.
ReplyDeleteAbove from Camerin McManus
DeleteI think the filmmaker is trying to convey that democracy is viewed differently by a lot of people and that democracy impacts peoples lives unequally. Something that was new to me was the raw statistical data of racial disparities in homicide related deaths. To me, learning of this statistical data and personal experiences, it is appalling how much evidence there is of racial disparities across all facets of democracy. The film contributed to my understanding of democracy in a way that it changed my entire view of democracy all together. I know now just how differently democracy affects the wealthy, the impoverished, the majority and the minority; furthermore, how each individual's experience with democracy is so radically different argues that not everyone gets the same experience.
ReplyDeleteThe filmmaker is trying to convey that democracy is more subjective than most might think. I wasn't aware of the origins of democracy and it was interesting to see the role it played in society before us. This film helped me reinforce the idea that democracy, or any system of government, isn't a one-size-fits-all kind of thing. It doesn't always align with everyone's individual values. No system will be "perfect" but I'm curious to know which one will truly work best within our society.
ReplyDeleteIt seems that the filmmaker wants to demonstrate the idea that democracy is too complex to sum up in a single word or definition. She gives the audience a variety of perspectives by conducting interviews with members of the public and educators. The way that minorities and genders are shown in this film is interesting in my opinion, as it is a significant aspect of modern society. The way that democracy is represented in other nations was something new to me as I had never seen it from that point of view. As a result, I was able to learn more about democracy in general by examining this film.
ReplyDeleteThe message that the filmmaker is trying to convey in this movie is that democracy is a complex system that effects different people in different ways. The inclusion of many different interviews with a diverse background of people was a good way of showing the many different points of view under a democratic system. While we all may be living under the same system, the effects that it has on on us and our feelings towards the system can vary from person to person.
ReplyDeleteHugh
DeleteI think the filmmaker is trying to convey that democracy does not have one set format. We just keep working on it and hope for the best. We as a country understand that we have a voice and want to use it, however, nobody truly understands what a democratic is and what it is not. We just hope we're doing a good job and that we are picking the best people to convey our voices to the government.
ReplyDeleteBrock: The filmmakers are trying to portray to the audience that democracy may have a set definition online or in a dictionary, the true definition is based upon the person. Democracy can be defined by many terms or phrases.
ReplyDeleteI think the filmmaker is trying to convey that democracy is not limited to the google definition. Democracy is much bigger than that and can be define in many different ways. The filmmaker shows this by having interviews with different people. These people all have different views on democracy.
ReplyDeleteI think that the filmmaker is trying to show that there is not one specific way of democracy among the whole world. The interviews show how democracy is different and always changing in other places.
ReplyDeleteSkyla garnett
DeleteI think the filmmaker aimed to depict the diverse thoughts and interpretations people have about democracy. This intrigues me because, I was taught that democracy had a singular meaning universally understood by all. The film helped me realize that democracies can exist in various places, each with its unique perspectives.
ReplyDeleteAfter watching the film, it has become apparent that democracy is not necessarily viewed the same across different cultures that partake in it. The way democracy is viewed, along with the demands it must aid in meeting, is dependent on the needs and demands of the cultures that use this process. This open-ended view of democracy is what I believe the filmmaker's intent was behind the film. I think that the open-endedness in itself was something that I learned while watching this film. Since I am used to an American take on democracy, I did not consider that other countries might view it differently based on the needs of the people. This film has made me more aware that democracy is not as refined as I thought. It is, moreover, a practice based on the interpretation of the culture, needs, and wants of a community.
ReplyDeleteThe filmmakers demonstration and descriptions of democracy is conveyed through varying perspectives from various backgrounds, from history to today. The historical background of Plato, Socrates, Athens and more provided a rather strong foundation of issues that arise from varying power structures, albeit democracy or otherwise, prompt a discussion that applies to situations today. Democracy as a conversation amongst the people rather than an arguement between majorities and minorities is conveyed very well in the film, it was intriguing to learn of different backgrounds and their experience with democracy/freedom around the world.
ReplyDeleteThis post is from Kaya Harripersad.
DeleteJulie: The filmmaker is making the point that everyone should have their own definition of Democracy. There's not one definition that we should all adopt. I learned more about the different backgrounds of the country's democracy and what it took to get to their place now. The film helped me realize that Democracy, in theory, is good, but it's not necessarily good in reality to use.
ReplyDeleteI believe the point that the filmmakers were trying to make with the film was that democracy isn't set in stone. The definition is very loose-fitting, and it can vary depending on who you ask. It's something that everyone, everywhere is trying to achieve this perfect democracy. Also, I believe that they showed that democracy is in a way unachievable. They showed so many places throughout the years, and it's never been done to its full extent the way it's intended.
ReplyDeletejohanna
DeleteThe film's exploration of democracy's complexity, varying interpretations, and unexpected facets, such as the conditions in prisons and the vulnerability of jail libraries, was eye-opening. The global perspective offered insights into different democratic systems, challenging my preconceptions. The documentary, especially in its examination of the flaws in the US version of democracy, prompted a critical reevaluation. Overall, the documentary significantly broadened my understanding, leaving me with a more nuanced and thoughtful perspective on the intricacies of democracy.
ReplyDeleteI think that the film-maker was trying to convey that everyone's definition of democracy is different in many ways. Everybody has a different way of thinking which can affect that persons definition of democracy. The film maker shows this by having different races and ethnicities in the film because everyone of there definitions of democracy is different.
ReplyDelete