What do you make of Ayers' way of talking about teaching? Did he bring up any new/different ways of understanding the enterprise? Any other thoughts?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1/22…Labaree’s “From Citizen to Consumers”
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
What do you think the filmmaker is trying to convey about democracy? What was new to you? What did the film contribute to your understanding...
-
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
Have you done much thinking about democracy and what our schools might/should have to do with it? If so, what have you been thinking? If not...
I really liked how he used such strong words such as a teacher having a whip in modern day education. Or when he was talking about a made up person in the education system how he used the words predigested when talking about the information. Also, how when talking about the same girl he said she was entirely fated. I liked that because I totally agree and think that the education system is really just systematically teaching compliance. However, when thinking about education I normally only think about public/private schooling. But, in this chapter at one point he started talking about sermons and preachers and how they teach you how to live. And I had never really thought of education in that way. I never thought about education in other forms other than k-12. So that brought out a lot of just ideas about different ways people may be taught like in churches or even in their jobs and how that could also play into the whole idea of just teaching compliance.
ReplyDeleteRight away, I was taken aback by Ayers' talking of teaching. Not in a bad way, but in a way that made me appreciate becoming a teacher even more. I really liked his definition that said, "Teaching at its best, is an enterprise that helps human beings reach the full measure of their humanity. It really resonated with me his connection to education and humanity because I have never seen it expressed like that before. I appreciated that Ayers mentions that as educators we must recognize the social order around our students. This was also new to me because I feel like some teachers only want to teach the course their way, and ignore the outside environment. Overall, I enjoyed reading the article and understanding Ayers' thoughts.
ReplyDeleteAyers talks about teaching in a way that makes it known that it is the foundation of any nation. It is our humanity according to him, and I agree. "A teacher can help sort out the difference between a fact and a choice. Still, at least one chooses and one lives with the consequences of that choice." This quote made me go back and think about many things that I've been taught in my life and how if one small fact was changed, it would have changed my opinion on many things. Teachers influence society on a massive scale, and they have the power to shape the world around them, whether that be in a good or bad way. Ayers made me think about society, our government, and the job of teaching in an entirely different light.
ReplyDeleteEli- I like how he talks about teaching in an admirable way while still pointing out it's flaws. He makes it clear that teaching is very important but that the school system teachers compliance. I also think his point about education outside of school is interesting. I never really think about school outside of k-12 and college.
ReplyDeleteI feel that he talks about teaching in a good way and while doing this he was able to bring up some very valuable key points. He mentions that teaching is a job that will help students reach their full measure of humanity. He also states that teachers can help you when it comes to making choices by sorting out differences between each one. Although this is said the learner will choose the one they feel best about and go on with the consequence of it good or bad. This was some stuff that stuck out to me even if I already knew it, it gave me a better understanding behind what teachers/schools are there for. They do more but these key points stuck out to me most.
ReplyDeleteI think Ayers has a very strong way of talking about education due to his strong opinions on in. One thing I found interesting was how he said school could either be built around enlightenment or built around oppressiveness. I think he's right i don't believe you could have a school that is oppressive and also focuses on human enlightenment.
ReplyDeleteI like Ayers belief that the school and education is the heart of society. It was a new idea to me prior to taking this class but I feel that teaching and the culture of schools has a much larger impact on people than they think. With our society encouraging individualistic ideals, I think people forget how impactful the experiences we have with schools can be on society as a whole. Ayers does a great job of showing that teaching has the potential to impact our society far more than we think.
ReplyDeleteI appreciated how Ayers spoke about teaching as the basis of finding our humanity. As he continued on he made great analogies about different teaching techniques and why they are objectively good or bad and how we need to identify those to be good teachers and also people. Something he brought up that I hadn't really thought of before is when he said that "education is always for something and against something else". He then went on to explain more about that and I agree with him that education should be a way to better ourselves and those we teach and open them up to the world, not suppress them and make people compliant.
ReplyDeleteI liked how he discussed current methods of teaching but, while doing so he also looked back on how American schools were for those who were considered "uncivilized". school these days do not feel like a place I can grow as a person finding my own individual identity to build my own wants and needs up but rather a constructed system that's put in for me to "learn" but I don't feel as if I'm learning to be myself but yet another product of the American "reform" system.
ReplyDeleteThe way that he referred to many forms of teaching stuck out to me because I have always been a firm believer that there is no one single correct way to teach. Ayers also talked about school being the heart of society, and I agree with that statement fully because, as teachers, we are with somebody else's child more often than they are. Teachers have a role in every kid's life that goes beyond just teaching them math.
ReplyDelete-Brock
DeleteI like Ayer’s honesty about the school system. He highlights the pros of the system but doesn’t hold back on telling the problems of it. I think he did a great job at explaining the connection between education and humanity. He goes over the good and bad parts of education.I think he brought out new ways of thinking about education. Instead of praising the system, he told us the truth about it.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Ayers perspective on teaching. He made a lot of great points on how an authoritarian approach to teaching is not how we should practice education. I also like that he mentioned schools becoming “little training prisons.” The school to prison pipeline is something I feel needs more recognition, as I work with kids more. Overall, I enjoyed his in depth analysis of education and his critiques of the system.
ReplyDeleteAyers’ take on teaching, I believe, is a good way of looking at the topic. Ayers does a really good job of emphasizing the importance of receiving an education in our society. It seems like in recent times, especially among students, the importance of school is simply based on the fact that you have to go. However, Ayers does a good job of pointing out the fact that teaching and education is what lays out the foundation of our society while also pointing out some important flaws of the system as well.
ReplyDeleteHugh
DeleteAyers emphasizes the importance of teachers influence on the future of the world. It is crucial for teachers to cultivate a learning environment that not only stimulates stimulates for learning academia but also stimulates individual growth and discovery. This compassionate approach is important in any environment of learning, for teachers to have ethical and moral values that align with the success of their students beyond the academia of the classroom. The emphasis on humanity is also something I have always been passionate about. Humanity in all aspects, good, bad, and otherwise, is important to demonstrate, so students can navigate the sociocultural, political experiences students face, and the intersectionality of their experiences, and the importance of learning to understand.
ReplyDeleteThe way Ayers discussed education as the basis of discovering our humanity struck me as profound. Throughout the article, he provided some excellent parallels regarding various teaching methods and the reasons behind their objective goodness or badness, as well as how to recognize individuals who are both good instructors and good people. His statement that "education is always for something and against something else" is something he brought up that I hadn't really given much thought to previously. He continued to elaborate, and I agree with him that education should not be used to repress people or make them obedient, but rather as a means of bettering ourselves and the people we teach and opening them up to the outside world.
ReplyDeleteAyere emphasizes that if you want to teach you have to take risks and break rules and I agree because when you're a teacher sometime you can't follow the curriculum you got to sometimes slow down and actually make sure the kids understand and make it interesting and fun cause they will always remember that. Most of the time.
ReplyDeleteI agree with what Ayere was talking about in the video. He was really honest with all his facts about how you have to take risk and break rules. Unfortunately that is true and you can get in trouble but you have to think about the outcomes of it.
ReplyDeleteAyers talks about teaching in a way that grabs attention, comparing it to holding a "whip" and pointing out how schools often push us to just follow the rules. He also mentions teaching happening outside the regular school spots, like in sermons or at work. He says teaching should help us become our best selves, which makes a lot of sense. It's like teachers guide us in making choices and living with the results. Ayers also sees the flaws in how schools sometimes make us just go along with things. In a nutshell, Ayers makes us think about teaching in a bold way, showing both its strengths and where it could do better.
ReplyDeleteAyers' comments in the video carried a great deal of weight. More teachers should watch this video to learn that, in teaching, sometimes they'll have to take risks for the students. Working at the given curriculum level might be too much for the students to comprehend, so the teacher should explain the lessons to the students. I had never considered sermons and preachers teachers, but he brought up a great example of them being the teachers of life.
ReplyDeleteJulie