Monday, January 15, 2024

2/19…Precious Knowledge

React to this film. If possible, relate this film to today’s CRT controversy. 

25 comments:

  1. I think this movie was very beautiful. It resonated with me as a hispanic person who is pursuing further education. I just feel like it's insane to me that classes like this in this sort of context violate some kind of law. It kind of reminds me of how today there are some African American AP studies classes are not being allowed to be taught due to the nature of their content. it just feels like the same story repeating itself in history. One thing in the movie that stood out to me was when the senator guy said that the class painted Thomas Jefferson as a racist. Like, they're scared that it'll tear down the figures that we have for so long worshiped, but honestly if there are things we can tear them down about then maybe we shouldn't be worshiping them.
    one line I just want to mention was the lady who said "this is not the way hispanic parents want their kids to be acting". That line made my jaw drop, because as a hispanic person, I know my hispanic mother would be so proud of me for standing up to such injustice. That comment felt like it had racist undertones as well. It was just astonishing to me that they went into that classroom and saw what was happening and instead of seeing a community of people who support each others endeavors and are just that a supportive community, and see people who are breaking the law.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think the movie was very interesting. Its fascinating to see how battles today repeat themselves like with CRT. Both of these things are taking the critical approach to education. I think that the movie shows a lot of representation and also shows some of the same battles we still fight today. -Eli

    ReplyDelete
  3. I was shown this movie in another class a couple years ago. It still baffles me that people are so caught up in their own ways, that they feel the need to try and rid others of things they believe in. At some point it's not about what you believe in, it's about ethnic cleansing. White washing schools even more so than what they are. I think people in power (more specifically white men), are scared of minorities "overthrowing" them. Education about about race and cultures leads people to "act out". They don't want to be the minority, so limiting education about things that would cause others to speak up is their way of controlling the population.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I just find it interesting that we deal with a lot of the same issues that have been going on for such a long time with not a lot of change

    ReplyDelete
  5. This movie was so mind-blowing to me, but at the same time, it didn't surprise me. The fact that so many people could see what was happening in these schools and still actively worked against these kids trying to get a well-rounded education is disheartening. especially because this is still happening to this day. CRT should be taught in schools; you can see its impact on all of the students in this documentary. POC are the foundation of America; erasing our culture is a disservice to all. 

    ReplyDelete
  6. I was really moved by this movie. As a Hispanic woman in education, this film hit home for me. The education system for minorities needs to change, and this movie was very informative about that. Unfortunately, this film is from years ago and is still a present-day issue. As a future educator, it is important to understand the struggles of our system and the fight people have to give for change. It needs to be addressed more and as a community, we need to do better.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This movie was really good to me. It contained good information and it really hit home because we are still dealing with some of these problems now. The education system for minorities is not good and needs to change. Its crazy to me that we are still having some of these problems after so many years. To make things even worse people are against it which to me is just wrong because everybody deserves a well rounded education, regardless of your race and ethnicity.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This movie was pretty good to me. It allowed me to gain knowledge about stuff that's pretty important to know when going into the education field. I feel that the educational system is really unfair for the minorities because they aren't given as much of a change to their education as others may be given. It really made me happy to see these teachers working with these students to give them the education that they deserve. It's ridiculous that we still have to deal with problems like these. I personally believe that no matter your race, religious background, or who you are in general you deserve the right to an education.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This was a very impactful movie for me as it demonstrated how the education system views the expression of heritage in their schools. It was a shock to me to how insanely wrong and ignorant that white politician was. It relates to CRT because this is an example of the education system controlling the type of knowledge children are exposed to. In this film, they demonstrate that protecting the knowledge of heritage is important for community development, but the education system operates in a manner that unfairly oppresses.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This movie was pretty upsetting for me. It was hard to watch so many people try to tear down a program that was obviously benefitting students. I see how the situation in the movie relates to CRT today because I see a lot of the same racist reactions from people who are angry about children learning the correct history of our country.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I absolutely loved the movie along with the message within it. It’s sad to see that even when students are trying there will always be someone waiting to find the faults in their achievements. As a student today it’s very difficult to excel when I know there are people waiting to erase my history out of any form of education today. CRT is a major part of history. There’s too many secrets within our government why should we have to be blind to how people of color have been treated throughout time. It is fear that drives these people to react in such a negative way towards CRT when we as students of color are only trying to learn.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Julie- The movie was very interesting to me, because it had the parallels between the past issues and today’s issues. The program in the movie was helping the students, but people wanted to shut it down. The movie reminded me of teachers I had in the past who always gave me the support to do well. This movie also reminded me of the movie and story, The Freedom Writers. That movie is about a culture and race war, and focuses on students that aren’t given the tools or the chance by the head of the English department to excel. It took one teacher to help them, and fight for them to have the same kind of education as the rest of the school.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I found this video to be really influential since it showed how the educational system feels about students embracing heritage in the classroom. I was shocked by the white politician's craziness and ignorance. It is related to CRT since this is an illustration of how the educational system restricts the kinds of information that kids are exposed to. In this movie, it is shown that while preserving cultural knowledge is crucial for community growth, the way the educational system functions unfairly oppresses people.

    ReplyDelete
  14. This documentary was incredibly jarring to watch, knowing how recent this discourse surrounding educational curriculum, especially during a time of apparent progressivism with the election of former President Barack Obama. The discourse surrounding CRT today, is unfortunately due to the fact that many people are uneducated on what is actually being taught in schools regarding discussions of race and slavery, similarly to how Tom Horne was very ignorant and refused to attend the classroom setting. This is a holistic problem with media outlets producing articles and stories that make CRT a 'buzzword'; what is viewed as CRT is just the intersectionality and impacts of history on institutions today. If we were truly 'Americans' it is critical to for us to understand our history and how it has shaped our present, the good, the bad, and the ugly. Not teaching history, culture, and more, we are contributing to the marginalization and erasure of voices and history, whereas we can do so much more with the inclusion of voices.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I found this film to be very interesting and almost angering. The way these kids don't get much and the one thing they do get is going to be taken way? it just makes me very mad. I think that this film really did a good job representing the CRT by its censorship. Censorship is the real problem here.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I appreciate films like these because they open up a conversation that needs to be had. It highlights significant issues regarding the value of ethnic studies in the classroom, cultural representation, and the difficulties experienced by teachers trying to offer a more varied and inclusive curriculum. It's always surprising and quite scary to see how passionate people are about being less inclusive within education.
    Both CRT and the film challenge common narratives and push for educational policies that take into consideration students' different learning experiences.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This film was mind blowing to me because it shows how naive people of power can be toward the school system. It is frustrating to see the one thing that these kids look forward to and love being taken away from them. People of power over the education system need to do better with understanding and witnessing what is happening first-hand before they make decisions on it.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I thoroughly enjoyed this film. It presented valuable insights that resonated with me, particularly because many of the issues it addressed are still prevalent today. The educational challenges faced by minority communities are disheartening and require reform. It's astonishing that these issues persist despite the passage of time. What's even more troubling is the opposition to change, as I believe everyone should have access to a comprehensive education, irrespective of their race or ethnicity.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Johanna- Watching this film I felt many strong emotions, especially being Latin American seeing how racist and naive people can be is infuriating. The program they have created for the Latin American community is wonderful, and seeing the kids passionate about school and prioritized for once, when they have always been pushed aside is refreshing. The most frustrating part is that once they saw how well the program was doing, and how much the students were enjoying it and benefitting from it they wanted to rip it away. It's something that happens time and time again without fail, and it's not just happening to latin Americans, it's happening to every community that is primarily poc.

    ReplyDelete
  20. The movie was hard to watch because the program was beneficial and the white old men were trying to tear it down but I really love how the students didn't give up. I see CRT still today with African Americans studying and learning black history and teaching the true history and white people don't like it because they want to seem innocent

    ReplyDelete
  21. I think this film was an important watch. I felt the film did a good job at showing what the program was about and how beneficial it was for the kids. I was frustrated by the senator trying to shut it down claiming that it was racist. I think this is very familiar to the conversation around Critical Race Theory, people claiming that talking about race and how it has influenced America is racist. I think it is very damaging to social justice issues because the argument that talking about race is racist lacks a fundamental understanding of systemic racism and how it has affected the American infrastructure and economy.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Watching the movie, I was struck by its relevance to current issues, particularly regarding Critical Race Theory in education. The film's focus on representation highlights ongoing struggles for equality.

    The entrenched biases depicted, leading to attempts to erase diverse perspectives, reveal systemic issues that echo ethnic cleansing. This suppression of knowledge about race and culture stems from a fear of minority empowerment perpetuated by those in power.

    ReplyDelete

1/22…Labaree’s “From Citizen to Consumers”

In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...