Page through the Nieto and Bode chapter. Identify a place where you see the influence of an asset approach. Do you see any vestiges of deficit thinking?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1/22…Labaree’s “From Citizen to Consumers”
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
What do you think the filmmaker is trying to convey about democracy? What was new to you? What did the film contribute to your understanding...
-
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
Have you done much thinking about democracy and what our schools might/should have to do with it? If so, what have you been thinking? If not...
A place where I see the influence of an asset approach is on page 142 where they talk about adapting the learning style to fit into students' cultural background. I see some vestiges of deficit thinking in parts with language that focuses mostly on students' deficiencies, challenges, or just deficits in general.
ReplyDeleteOne place in the Nieto and Bode chapter where I saw the influence of an asset is when the author writes about understanding and acknowledging the differences that students bring to school. Many teachers struggle to create a learning environment that all students can relate to and thrive in. The chapter mentions that some educators refuse to accept differences, which leads to dominant cultural norms. There is also a vestige of deficit thinking that is mentioned called "color blindness in classrooms." This is something that a teacher will experience when focus on their beliefs and refuse the differences within students. Instead of acknowledging a student's ethnicity, the teacher will diminish this by referring to all students as the same.
ReplyDeleteWhile reading the text, I found the influence of asset approach on page 145- "The way in which teachers approach topics of human difference and student identity, can make or break the class-room experience...cultivating teacher awareness of the multiplicity and intersectionality of the student identity is essential to a positive learning experience. An example of deficit thinking I found on pg 149- "The persistence of institutionalized racism can prevent schools from addressing each student's learning needs and identities."
ReplyDeleteThe influence of an asset approach in teachers is learning about the identities of all their students. This is an asset focused approach because the teachers are catering specifically to what their students might need. Instead of viewing students that they all need the same thing to succeed, teachers should do better by learning themselves what accommodations need to happen in order to provide support for all their students. An example of a deficit approach was the concept that mainstream US culture has a position of power and is outside of culture. This is a deficit perspective of thinking of culture as it "exoticize[s] those who are not in the cultural mainstream" (pg. 140).
ReplyDeleteGrant Pataky ^
DeleteBrock- Seeing your students as all individual people and providing what they need and knowing who they truly are as individuals is asset approach. A deficit approach would having a certain standard for all students, believing that because this student is happy then everyone else must be too.
ReplyDeleteA use of the asset approach that caught my attention was on page 150 of Gloria Ladson-Billings research about the teachers who were effective in teaching African American students. The teachers who would bridge black culture with the dominant culture would teach them in a way that keeps them active in their lessons and actually helps them learn. A difference I noticed was teachers approach to LGBTQ students and how they didn't care if it happened outside of their classrooms. That mindset isolates students and contributes to why many LGBTQ students struggle in schools. Tamara
ReplyDeleteAn asset approach I saw in the reading was visiting students families in order to gain a better understanding of each individual. A deficit approach I found was cultural discontinuities.
ReplyDeleteI see examples of asset approach when talking about taking students different cultural backgrounds into account when teaching them. A deficit approach is them assuming that everyone has the same intelligence type and can only fit in certain categories. -eli horne
ReplyDeleteOne place that I see asset approach being explained in a way I think is interesting is at the top of page 140. They say that "two offspring from the same parents, with the same culture and social class, and raised in substantially the same way, can turn out to be as different as night and day". I like this because it really exemplifies that culture and socioeconomic class really don't have much to do with how well a person can succeed in school. I think when starting to read this some remanence of deficit thinking was the example of teachers who say they don't see color they see everyone the same. I think teachers who say this sometimes to "be woke" but it just comes off super backwards. like I guess its a nice sentiment but it just is generally the wrong approach when we have to accept everyone /isn't/ the same and brings different things to our community.
ReplyDeleteI saw an example of an asset approach when it was mentioned that student and teacher relationships can improve or worsen the relationship with culturally responsive classrooms. Their example was that students and teachers with the same background had an easier time connecting.
ReplyDeleteThere were many different examples of asset approach however the baseline understanding was that students and teachers take an approach in understanding the cultural and social differences amongst the student and allow them to be educated and converse as one instead of taking the blinded “I don’t see color” method which in often times can do more harm than good
ReplyDeleteOn page 137, it states “But if we are serious about providing all students with educational equity, then students’ cultures and identities need to be seen not as a burden, a problem or even a challenge, but rather as assets on which to build.” I think this statement represents an asset approach well. As for the vestiges of deficit thinking, there was an example on page 147 of a language discontinuity. Teachers assumed students were “slow” as a result of them answering questions differently than expected.
ReplyDeleteNieto and Bode discussed asset approach within having multicultural education within a sociopolitical framework. They discuss not only celebrating cultural identities but also promoting self image, a crucial component of any students academic experience. However, as they discuss building up students by acknowledging their strengths and incorporating cultural knowledge, traditions, and languages into the curriculum, deficient thinking can still remain in different ways, such as unconscious bias. Even well-intentioned teachers may unintentionally reinforce negative stereotypes about certain cultural or linguistic groups.
ReplyDeleteThe place I saw asset approach was when he was talking about how all different children can bring different cultures to the the table and how they can have a better relationship with cultural friendly/ responsive class rooms.
ReplyDeleteOne place I saw the asset approach was when the author spoke about how each student is different and each student brings their differences into the classroom where they all mix together.
ReplyDeleteA place where I see the influence of asset approach in the text is when it talks about different learning styles. In teaching, it is important to remember that all students learn differently and it is necessary to do your best to adapt accordingly to make sure you are maximizing the potential learning of each student. Obviously it is impossible to fill the learning needs of every single student but at least making an effort is important. This approach of teaching does not consist of deficit thinking because it focuses purely on the individuals way of learning and nothing else.
ReplyDeleteHugh
DeleteA place I saw influence of asset approach in the Nieto and Bode chapter was when they mentioning adapting your teaching styles to each student individually. It mentioned to do this due to all students having different cultural backgrounds and learning needs. I think a deficit approach is looking at the students with these different cultural backgrounds and learning needs as a challenge or weakness. We should really see them just as we see everyone else and appreciate the different things they can bring to the table.
ReplyDeleteI saw great ways to incorporate the influence of asset approach in this chapter through the suggested avenues of understanding the strengths brought upon by diversity. The one that stuck out the most was involving families and reaching out often. This helps encourage family involvement, while also welcoming the cultural backgrounds the children bring through their families. This helps each culture learn about each other and build each other up. I think the deficit approach could come about when thinking that a child maintains weaknesses because of their differences in cultural backgrounds.
ReplyDeleteA place where I see the influence of the asset approach in the text is on page 137, which states “But if we are serious about providing all students with educational equity, then students’ cultures and identities need to be seen not as a burden, a problem or even a challenge, but rather as assets on which to build.” and it also talks about the different learning styles and forms of teaching. Since I want to be a special education teacher I know that it is important to remember that all students learn differently and you have to try your best to adapt to make sure you learn each student and the cultural background.
ReplyDeleteA compelling explanation of the asset approach can be found on page 140, where it's noted that despite having the same parents, culture, and social upbringing, two siblings can be vastly different from each other. This illustrates the point that success in education isn't necessarily determined by cultural or socioeconomic factors. Initially, there may be traces of deficit thinking, as seen in the example of teachers claiming to be colorblind, which can come across as outdated. While the intention may be positive, it overlooks the diversity and unique contributions individuals bring to our communities, emphasizing the need to embrace these differences rather than assuming uniformity.
ReplyDeleteOne example of the asset approach to teaching can be the idea of learning styles, page 142 "A focus on rigid learning styles is problematic because of its tendency to dichotomize learning; it is doubtful that a process as complex as learning can be characterized as having only two poles, four quadrants, or five characteristics, whatever the theory may assert. Hence, we use the term learning preferences because it is a more flexible way of approaching differences in learning. A good example is the case of Hoang Vinh, who loved working in cooperative groups, a learning preference that is not usually associated with Vietnamese students. Thus, although learning-style research can be helpful in identifying learning differences related to ethnicity and culture, its misapplication also runs the risk of oversimplification and stereotyping and can be used as a rationale for poor or inequitable teaching."
ReplyDeleteCamerin McManus ^
DeleteThe text underscores the importance of educators acknowledging and embracing student diversity. Despite this, some struggle to create inclusive environments, perpetuating dominant cultural norms like "color blindness in classrooms."
ReplyDeleteIt emphasizes the need for teachers to recognize and value the multiplicity of student identities, but institutionalized racism often hampers this. educators must prioritize an asset-based approach, actively learning about and catering to students' identities and needs. Rejecting deficit perspectives, such as exoticizing non-mainstream cultures, is crucial for fostering inclusive learning environments.
One place where I find the asset approach explained intriguingly is on page 140, where it mentions that "two siblings from identical parents, sharing the same cultural and socioeconomic background, and raised similarly, can grow up to be vastly different individuals." This idea highlights that cultural background and socioeconomic status are not determining factors for academic success. Initially, I thought of deficit thinking, particularly when teachers claim they don't notice differences in students' backgrounds but treat everyone equally. While this may seem like a progressive stance, it can come across as misguided. It's important to acknowledge and embrace the diversity individuals bring to our communities rather than trying to homogenize everyone's experiences.
ReplyDelete