What was school discipline like where you went to school? Looking back, can you remember any teachers who did a particularly good job of managing their class? What did they do/not do?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1/22…Labaree’s “From Citizen to Consumers”
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
What do you think the filmmaker is trying to convey about democracy? What was new to you? What did the film contribute to your understanding...
-
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
Have you done much thinking about democracy and what our schools might/should have to do with it? If so, what have you been thinking? If not...
Back home my schools discipline was serious but that's only because there were a bunch of fights every week. They had to become very stern due to situations like these. Looking back there were multiple teachers who did do a good job with managing their classroom. I say this because they were very serious teachers and didn't do the joke around or anything of that nature.
ReplyDelete^^This is Taleah
ReplyDeletediscipline in my school was pretty inconsistent from my point of view. overall, my school was VERY diverse, yet most of the punishment was directed towards POC. for instance, one time I got dress coded for wearing a tank top with jeans in the spring, while a lot of other people who were dressed a lot less appropriately walked by. I do think dress coding is most of the time not a good idea so I don't think anyone should have been dress coded in that situation, , but I do wish they had taken the same measures with others as they did with me. so thats just an example of the inconsistency in my school.
ReplyDeleteI cant think of any specific examples of teachers, but the one thing I can say about that is that in classes where teachers treated us as actual humans as opposed to subordinates, there were less issues.
At my school we had our big rules like dress code, and suspension if you were fighting, and other types of rules you typically will fine. As far as in the classroom it varied from teacher to teacher. Some were more strict with their discipline and some weren't. For example I got lunch detention for the first (and only might I add) time in 7th grade because I didn't get a parent to sign my report card (might I also add I had straight A's). In high school some teachers would pass out referrals which lead to in school suspension like it was candy. I heard one teacher had a policy if you had your phone out or even if it went off during class, it was instant ISS. I'd say the teachers who were chill with most things but had their list of don'ts and stuck to them were the ones where kids would act out the least. It felt like their was a mutual respect. The teachers who were too nice were the ones where people would take advantage of.
ReplyDeleteDiscipline in my school was very biased toward the people they favored. The only thing that would get you in trouble every time is if you were involved in a fight or destruction of their property. There were more teachers who were lenient with rules, but the ones who enforced the rules were extremely strict about them.
ReplyDeleteMy schools were sometimes very light on the rules I say the kids kinda did whatever they wanted anyways so I could tell the adults and staff kinda gave up halfway thru the year sometimes they’d give up within the first quarter however I would say things like fighting and dress code were always heavily influenced it was the main thing they could get kids gone for so I guess that’s why they enforced it so much because it’s the only power they really had.
ReplyDeleteAt the schools I went to the discipline varied from each kid. Sometimes teachers had favorites and chose which kid to be more harsh on. We had one rule which was dress code that they only followed with some people and not all. Looking back on which teacher did good was my success teacher. She helped me with my classes and work that I needed help on. She made sure to help everybody who needed it.
ReplyDeleteAt my school, we did an excellent job of having a welcoming yet disciplined environment. Our principal was very involved with student activities, which helped when it came to any conflicts. There were not a lot of fights or drama at my school, which was impressive since my high school was pretty large. In terms of the classroom, teachers did have control of their settings most of the time. This was enforced by interacting with the students and families, providing ground rules, and having a safe space.
ReplyDeleteIn elementary school I remember being discipline with behavioral techniques (red card, yellow, green card, etc.) but in middle school and high school the discipline was more individual problem focused. I found that the teachers who could manage their classes the best were the ones who could inspire the students and engage them with the material. My 6th grade science teacher Mr. Peck was so awesome on the first day of class he made this huge fireball and the whole class was immediately engaged. I believe this is what allowed him to gain respect and admiration from the students and therefore, he could control the class easily.
ReplyDeleteGrant Pataky^
DeleteDiscipline was varied from teacher to teacher at my schools, but it was consistent with the administrators. Most of my teachers had rules that were unique to their classrooms in addition to the basic ones that everyone had. I had a Sociology teacher in high school that was determined to teach us the information that we needed while still allowing us to have moments where we had spontaneous student-led discussions. She wasn’t so strict that students felt like they couldn’t breathe in her classroom. I think everyone in my class found that to be really nice because we all still got our work done.
ReplyDeleteDiscipline at my high school was not really effective. I saw the school trying but didn't really know how to put it in place but no one really cared because they weren't frightened by the office or no one really got sent to the office unless you got into a fight. But in elementary school discipline was more of a mind game with the red, yellow, and green card trying to get the kids to listen. In middle school, the kids would listen more because you'll go to the office for punishment and get a call home.
ReplyDeleteCiara Norfleet
DeleteSchool discipline when I went to school was inconsistent and embarrassing. Some teacher asked students to stand up and move their assigned card down when misbehaving. This was embarrassing to do in front of the whole class and I feel like didn’t fix the misbehaving issue. I can not think of any teachers from my k-12 years that disciplined well in my opinion.
ReplyDeleteIn my school, there were overarching rules such as the dress code and consequences like suspension for fights, which were pretty standard. However, within classrooms, disciplinary styles varied widely among teachers. Some were stricter, while others were more lenient. In high school, some teachers handed out referrals leading to in-school suspension quite liberally. I had one teach my 12 grade year in government class who had a strict no-phone policy, she would try to call my mother if I didn't put my phone in the cubby, I felt as though I was too old for that and felt it was unnecessary.
ReplyDeleteKamorah^^^
DeleteBig rules like the dress code, suspension for fighting, and other types of rules that usually resulted in fines were in place at my school. Regarding the classroom, it differed depending on the teacher in charge. While some were more lenient in their discipline, others weren't. Some high school teachers would give out referrals for everything, which resulted in in-school suspension. I've had a teacher who implemented an immediate ISS policy if a student brought their phone to class or it went off. The teachers who, in my opinion, were the least likely to have their students act out were those who were laid back about most things but who also adhered to a list of rules because there seemed to be mutual respect between them. I found that individuals would take advantage of teachers who were overly accommodating.
ReplyDeleteSchool discipline was unequal at my school. Often, the teachers and administration would pick who deserved the punishment, and it was always inconsistent. My principle's main punishment was these things he called clinics, where you had to meet up with the teacher that you got in trouble with and have a conversation on how to not do what you were doing wrong. The clinics were also inconsistent, with teachers not punishing their favorites. One of my teachers was always consistent in her rules and punished accordingly by making the students serve their clinics and go to the principal for three violations.
ReplyDeleteThe school discipline system at my school was very inconsistent and quite racist. It was unfair for students of color because they would be sent to ISS or given detention for doing absolutely nothing. The white guys in my school would act out every class and receive warning after warning. The teachers at my school would play into this by being unfair regarding discipline. My marketing teacher did an excellent job giving three warnings and then giving them detention. She wouldn't yell at the students but waited until after class to talk to them. This would avoid embarrassing them. She showed she cared about the students and wouldn't let their behavior affect their grades.
ReplyDeleteJulie
School disapline have been very different for me because I've been to about ten different schools. I remmeber being a lot younger and atending a private catholic school and our teachers would send up into the shuch when we were bad and we had to talk to the decan. In my public schools it was usually leaving the classroom or having a talk with parents. In high school however I would most likely get yelled at or you could be sent to the office.
ReplyDeleteJulia von Fahnestock
DeleteDiscipline in the school that I went to was never truly enforced, and if it was it was very inconsistent, especially after covid. There was a huge absents issue and many kids would wander around the hallways and be late to class. There was only one time when the admin attempted to do something and did a tardy sweep, but it was very ineffective. Also, I think that it's fair to say that the admin were very biased towards students, and they would always let athletes and student council off easy, whereas they would target other students.
ReplyDeleteJohanna
DeleteI found that dripline in my school was pretty lenient. I think this was mostly because after covid I was going to an alternative school and absences happened regularly and the only repercussions were in grades, yet to kids who hadn't been showing up they offered opportunities to pull their grade back. The most discipline I would see from a teacher would be our gym teacher which would send kids to the main office pretty regularly. In my opinion the reason she had to do this was because she got the most flack from students.
ReplyDeleteat my school discipline varied widely, from strict enforcement to inconsistency and bias. Dress code enforcement and disciplinary measures often differ among teachers and their favorites in class. I belive effective discipline is rooted in mutual respect and clear boundaries. Positive examples include supportive teachers and involved principals. Achieving balance requires fairness and consistency from educators and administrators alike.
ReplyDeleteSchool discipline involved a card system. growing up it was easy to perform well but there was an incidence and where I did not understand what the teacher was asking, mind you this is kindergarten, and I received a Red card. we were told that after the cafeteria we would be going to the gym, that is quite literally what was said. This was the day before Thanksgiving break so we had activities planned. the first stop was in fact the cafeteria where we got dressed up like a turkey or something like that. Afterwards, the teacher sent us unsupervised off with no further instruction. I was not the only student who was confused and trying to figure out where we are meant to go and having a reputation as a student who and did well, I was tasked with figuring out where we had to go. from the instructions from earlier, I understood that we had to go to the gym, so that is where I and my friends went. upon arrival to the gym which was a walk away, there was no one in there save one person, who might ask if they knew anything about a class that was supposed to be in there. they said no so we looked around to see if we could find our teacher and return to the classroom. Upon returning, because I took charge, I received a red card and was humiliated in front of my classmates. When we were sent to recess I sat alone in played with the gold ball and cried. my teacher knowing that it was out of character for myself allowed me to change my card and said I can go play with everyone else. this public humiliation form of discipline with the visual representations of a Behavior Card definitely put a lot of pressure on students like myself who performed well all the time, and did not really allow for the opportunity of improvement students who received yellow cards or red cards would only be penalized further. Teachers who fostered open communication and allowed students to learn from mistakes, I believe, had more positive classrooms. A safe environment allows students to not only succeed but also to make mistakes and improve. Early childhood is a crucial time for developing compassion, and a system that discourages improvement hinders that growth.
ReplyDeleteSchool discipline often entailed sending children to the office or emailing parents. I do not remember too specifically how the course of school discipline went. I believe that this method of discipline caused many children in my classes to hate their teachers. There were, however, some teachers who did a better job at mitigating problems by communicating openly with the students. I believe that the children in my class felt more comfortable with these teachers as a result.
ReplyDelete